Ingredient guide

Evidence grade, daily amount, what to look for and when to drop it, in numbers. Evidence C is always 'No need to buy' in results.

21 ingredients

Omega-3

Evidence A
EPA+DHA · dogs and cats

Omega-3 may support joint health and skin and coat health.

Daily amount

Dog joints: 75–100 mg EPA+DHA per kg of body weight a day (34–45 mg per lb; studies range 50–220 mg/kg). Lower for skin and coat. The dog upper limit is 370 mg × body weight (kg)^0.75. For cats, follow the weight chart on the label.

What to look for
  • Fish oil that lists EPA and DHA separately in mg
  • Contains vitamin E
  • Skip flaxseed oil (ALA): dogs and cats convert little of it to EPA/DHA
  • Skip cod liver oil: it also carries vitamins A and D
When to drop or cut back

Before surgery or with blood-thinning meds, ask your vet first. Cut back if you see loose stool or fishy burps.

Glucosamine · chondroitin

Evidence C · no need to buy
joints · dogs and cats

A 2022 meta-analysis in dogs and cats found no clear benefit. For joints, omega-3 comes first.

Daily amount

No need to buy.

When to drop or cut back

A 2022 meta-analysis in dogs and cats found no clear benefit. For joints, omega-3 comes first.

powder · dogs and cats

Green-lipped mussel may support joint health.

Daily amount

Per label.

What to look for
  • Lists mussel powder in mg
  • Labeled for the species (dog or cat)
When to drop or cut back

Skip it if you already give fish-oil omega-3; they overlap.

Probiotic

Evidence B
strain · CFU · dogs and cats

Probiotics may support gut health.

Daily amount

Per the weight chart on the label. Judge after 2 weeks.

What to look for
  • Names the strain (e.g. Enterococcus faecium SF68)
  • States CFU guaranteed through the expiry date
  • Skip products that only say 'probiotic blend'
When to drop or cut back

Stop if the stool chart doesn't move after 2 weeks. With blood or vomiting, see a vet first.

Oral care

Evidence A
VOHC accepted · dogs and cats

An oral-care product. It doesn't replace brushing.

Daily amount

Per the label of a VOHC-accepted product.

What to look for
  • VOHC accepted for that species (awarded for trial data showing over 20% less plaque or tartar)
  • Don't use dog-accepted products on cats
When to drop or cut back

Without VOHC acceptance, skip it.

Lutein

Evidence C · no need to buy
tear stains · dogs and cats

Tear stains mostly come from eyelid or tear-duct shape that makes tears overflow. Evidence that supplements reduce them is weak.

Daily amount

No need to buy.

When to drop or cut back

Tear stains mostly come from eyelid or tear-duct shape that makes tears overflow. Evidence that supplements reduce them is weak.

for home-made diets · dogs and cats

Fills vitamins and minerals that home-made diets often lack.

Daily amount

Home or raw diets only, per label.

What to look for
  • Lists vitamin D in IU
  • Don't use human products
When to drop or cut back

Drop it if you switch to a complete food. Keep total vitamin D under the limit with other products.

4+ weeks · dogs and cats

Alpha-casozepine may help with calm behavior.

Daily amount

Per the weight chart, at least 4 weeks.

What to look for
  • Has a feeding chart by weight
  • Give at least 4 weeks before judging
When to drop or cut back

No evidence for one-day use, like thunder or fireworks.

L-theanine

Evidence C · no need to buy
calming · dogs and cats

A common calming ingredient, but we found no placebo-controlled studies. For calming we go with alpha-casozepine.

Daily amount

No need to buy.

When to drop or cut back

A common calming ingredient, but we found no placebo-controlled studies. For calming we go with alpha-casozepine.

Hairball care

Not yet reviewed
fiber · cats

May help pass hairballs.

Daily amount

Per label.

What to look for
  • Lists fiber content as a number
  • Made for cats
When to drop or cut back

If vomiting several times a week, see a vet first.

Cranberry

Not yet reviewed
urinary · dogs and cats

Cranberry may support urinary health.

Daily amount

Per label.

What to look for
  • Lists cranberry content in mg
When to drop or cut back

If no urine comes out, it's a vet emergency, not a supplement issue.

Taurine

Essential nutrient
essential for cats · cats

Taurine is an essential nutrient for cats. They can't make enough on their own.

Daily amount

Per label, matched to the home or raw recipe.

What to look for
  • Cat supplement designed for home-made or raw diets
  • Lists the amount in mg
When to drop or cut back

Complete cat foods already contain it.

L-lysine

Evidence C · no need to buy
Cat · cats

A 2015 systematic review found no evidence it works.

Daily amount

No need to buy.

When to drop or cut back

A 2015 systematic review found no evidence it works.

Vitamin C

Evidence A
Guinea pig

Guinea pigs can't make vitamin C.

Daily amount

10–30 mg per kg of body weight a day. Up to 50 mg if young, pregnant or recovering.

What to look for
  • Chewable tablets listing mg per tablet
  • Skip water additives: vitamin C in water drops to 20% after 8 hours
When to drop or cut back

If fortified pellets and veggies cover it, they're already getting it. We don't advise over 50 mg per kg.

Calcium (no D3)

Evidence A
Gecko

Dust onto feeder insects.

Daily amount

2–3 times a week.

What to look for
  • Tub says 'no D3'
  • Reptile-specific
When to drop or cut back

A powdered complete diet may already include it.

Calcium + D3

Evidence A
Gecko

Without UVB, D3 comes from powder.

Daily amount

2–3 times a week without UVB; once a week or less with UVB.

What to look for
  • Lists D3 in IU
When to drop or cut back

Dusting every feeding while using a UVB lamp gives too much D3.

Gecko

Dust onto feeder insects.

Daily amount

Once a week.

What to look for
  • Reptile-specific with each ingredient amount listed
When to drop or cut back

Once a week is enough.

Budgie · cockatiel

Seed-heavy diets often run low on vitamin A and calcium.

Daily amount

Only while switching to pellets.

What to look for
  • Bird-specific, amounts listed
When to drop or cut back

Don't add if pellets are the staple. Vitamins A and D can get too high.

Vitamin C supplement

Evidence C · no need to buy
Rabbit

Rabbits make their own vitamin C.

Daily amount

Not needed.

What to look for
  • Hay at 75–80% of the diet
When to drop or cut back

Never needed.

Hamster supplement

Evidence C · no need to buy
Hamster

Evidence is weak.

Daily amount

Not needed.

What to look for
  • A complete-pellet diet comes first
When to drop or cut back

Never needed.

Water vitamins

Evidence C · no need to buy
Fish

Evidence is weak. Water (ammonia · nitrite) comes first.

Daily amount

Not needed.

What to look for
  • Confirm 0 with a water test kit first
When to drop or cut back

Never needed.